Cybersecurity Benchmarking

What is Cybersecurity Benchmarking?

Would you drive a car without knowing its safety rating? Just like crash tests help assess a vehicle’s safety, cybersecurity benchmarking helps organizations evaluate and improve their security posture. But what exactly does that mean, and how does it differ from a baseline?

Cybersecurity benchmarking is a strategic method of comparing an organization’s security performance against industry standards, peers, or best practices. It plays a key role in cybersecurity performance management, allowing businesses to track progress, identify weaknesses, and refine security strategies. By leveraging IT security benchmarks, companies ensure their defenses meet or exceed industry expectations.

Benchmark vs. Baseline: What’s the Difference?

Before diving deeper, let’s clarify a common point of confusion:

• Benchmark: A benchmark is a point of comparison—it evaluates your cybersecurity performance against industry standards, competitors, or best practices. It can also include internal comparisons across departments to assess performance variations and drive improvements.
• Baseline: A baseline is an internal reference point—it defines your organization’s current cybersecurity levels so you can measure progress over time. For instance, establishing that your mean time to detect (MTTD) is currently 24 hours serves as a baseline for future improvements.

Think of it this way: A baseline is where you start, and a benchmark is where you aim to be.

Cybersecurity benchmarking is the process of assessing security controls, policies, and risk management strategies against established standards. This helps organizations identify gaps, inefficiencies, and areas for improvement.

There are two main types of benchmarking:

1. Internal benchmarking: Comparing security performance across different departments or business units within the same organization.
2. External benchmarking: Measuring security against competitors, industry averages, or frameworks like NIST, CIS, ISO 27001, and SOC 2.

The Three Types of Cybersecurity Benchmarking

Cybersecurity benchmarking can take multiple forms, each offering unique insights:

1. Standards-Based Benchmarking

• Compares security controls against established frameworks such as NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF), ISO 27001, or CIS Controls.
• Helps ensure compliance with regulatory requirements and best practices.
• Example: A healthcare company uses the HIPAA Security Rule as a benchmark to evaluate its data protection practices, ensuring compliance with patient privacy laws.

2. Peer Benchmarking

• Measures security performance against industry peers or companies of similar size and risk profile.
• Provides insights into whether your organization is underperforming or leading the pack.
• Example: A financial institution compares its mean time to detect (MTTD) and mean time to respond (MTTR) against industry averages published in reports like the Verizon Data Breach Investigations Report.

3. Threat-Informed Benchmarking

• Evaluates security performance against real-world threat intelligence and attacker behavior.
• Focuses on whether defenses are aligned with current threats rather than just meeting compliance requirements.
• Example: A retail company benchmarks its email security against known phishing attack vectors, ensuring it is protected against the latest spear-phishing tactics used against similar businesses.

Key Cybersecurity Metrics for Benchmarking

To perform effective benchmarking, organizations must track and analyze critical cybersecurity metrics. Some essential ones include:

• Mean Time to Detect (MTTD): How long it takes to detect a security incident.
• Mean Time to Respond (MTTR): The speed of response after an incident is detected.
• Vulnerability Remediation Speed: The time required to patch vulnerabilities.
• Phishing Susceptibility Rate: The percentage of employees who fall for phishing attacks.
• Endpoint Protection Coverage: The percentage of devices protected by security solutions.
• Compliance Scores: Alignment with frameworks like NIST CSF, CIS Controls, or ISO 27001.

Tracking these metrics enables organizations to measure cybersecurity levels and improve decision-making.

Cybersecurity Levels: Where Does Your Organization Stand?

Organizations operate at different cybersecurity levels, ranging from minimal to highly mature:

1. Ad-hoc Security (Level 1): No formal cybersecurity strategy, reactive response to threats.
2. Basic Security (Level 2): Implementation of fundamental security controls (e.g., firewalls, antivirus software).
3. Intermediate Security (Level 3): Regular risk assessments, compliance with some industry frameworks.
4. Advanced Security (Level 4): Strong risk management, automated security controls, proactive threat detection.
5. Optimized Security (Level 5): Zero-trust architecture, AI-driven threat intelligence, full regulatory compliance.

Cybersecurity benchmarking helps organizations progress from lower levels to more advanced security postures by identifying gaps and prioritizing improvements.

Start Getting Value With
Centraleyes for Free

See for yourself how the Centraleyes platform exceeds anything an old GRC
system does and eliminates the need for manual processes and spreadsheets
to give you immediate value and run a full risk assessment in less than 30 days

Start Free Trial Now

Start Free Trial Now

Learn more about Cybersecurity Benchmarking
Click Here

How to Implement Cybersecurity Benchmarking

Step 1: Select the Right IT Security Benchmarks

Choose frameworks that align with your industry, such as:

• NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF)
• CIS Controls
• ISO 27001
• SOC 2 Compliance

Step 2: Collect and Analyze Cybersecurity Metrics

Gather data from security tools, incident reports, and compliance audits.

Step 3: Compare Against Industry Standards

Use benchmarking reports, peer data, and security framework guidelines to assess performance.

Step 4: Improve Cybersecurity Performance Management

Adjust security policies, implement new technologies, and set realistic cybersecurity goals based on benchmark comparisons.

When Should You Begin Cybersecurity Benchmarking?

Cybersecurity benchmarking is about taking action to enhance security performance. By tracking cybersecurity metrics, understanding cybersecurity levels, and leveraging IT security benchmarks, organizations can make data-driven improvements to stay ahead of threats.

So, where does your organization stand? Are you meeting the right cybersecurity benchmarks? The best time to assess your security posture was yesterday. The second-best time is now.