Best Fourth-Party Risk Management Strategies: Safeguard Your Business from Hidden Risks

You’ve nailed your third-party risk management (or at least you think you have). Then you take a closer look and find yourself staring at an expanding web of risk: the vendors behind your vendors, their vendors, and so on. Welcome to fourth-party risk management (FPRM)—where each layer you uncover reveals even more connections, and the potential risks multiply.

Fourth-party vendors are like your second cousins. You don’t choose them, and you probably don’t see them much. But—thanks to the shared gene pool—they’re still part of the family tree.

And just like your genes can quietly pass along “quirks” you didn’t ask for (like your great-uncle’s knack for snorting when he laughs), fourth-party vendors carry risks that can flow upstream into your business. 

It’s no wonder that frameworks like EU’s DORA and HIPAA don’t just focus on direct relationships. They require organizations to think beyond, tracing their risks outward to ensure a strong, resilient ecosystem. After all, your risk management is only as secure as the weakest link in this ever-growing chain.

Designed by Freepik

Digging Deep into the Vendor Ecosystem

It’s not easy to get a clear picture of what’s really going on beneath the polished surface your vendors portray—the “external layer” they’re flaunting, so to speak. Now imagine trying to peer deeper, into the relationships they rely on but don’t often advertise. Fourth-party risk takes you into this uncharted territory, requiring oversight not just of your direct vendors but of the suppliers and service providers they depend on.

In business, this means digging past the polished sales pitch and contract terms of your third parties to assess the suppliers and service providers they’re quietly leaning on. These hidden layers can introduce operational, cybersecurity, compliance, and reputational risks you may never see coming—until they arrive uninvited.

What Is Fourth-Party Risk Management?

Fourth-party risk management involves identifying, assessing, and mitigating risks introduced by the vendors or suppliers of your direct third parties. Essentially, it’s about monitoring the supply chain one layer deeper. For example:

• A cybersecurity firm you work with (third-party) might rely on a software provider (fourth-party).
• A cloud storage provider might outsource certain aspects of its service to another company.

These fourth-party relationships are often opaque, making them a blind spot for businesses that lack visibility into the extended supply chain. However, with increasing regulatory scrutiny and the rise of complex cyberattacks, it’s essential to incorporate fourth-party vendor risk management into your strategy.

Third-Party vs. Fourth-Party Risk

Let’s clarify the distinction:

• Third-party risk focuses on direct vendors or service providers you have a contractual relationship with.
• Fourth-party risk goes a layer deeper, examining the vendors and suppliers your third-party partners rely on to deliver their services.

For example:

If you use a cloud service provider (your third party vendor), they may rely on a data center provider or a software vendor (your fourth party vendor). A cybersecurity incident at this level can ripple through the entire supply chain, impacting your business.

The difference lies in visibility and control—while you can directly assess and monitor third parties, managing fourth-party supplier risk often requires indirect strategies.

The Layered Effect of Fourth-Party Risk

In fourth-party risk, each vendor doesn’t add to potential risks. It multiplies the risk. 

This is what I mean: if you’re managing 10 third-party vendors, each one of those vendors is likely relying on several suppliers or subcontractors to fulfill their part of the deal. So instead of managing just 10 relationships, you’re multiplying the number of potential risks by the number of suppliers or subcontractors each vendor relies on.

For example:

• 10 third-party vendors
• Each depends on 10 suppliers (this number can vary greatly)
• That means you’re now dealing with 100 additional relationships just from those ten vendors alone.

This multiplicative effect means that even a relatively small supply chain can have a huge number of indirect connections—and that requires careful management.

Why Fourth-Party Risk Management Matters

Fourth parties can pose a host of hidden risks, including:

• Cybersecurity Vulnerabilities: A breach at the fourth-party level can compromise sensitive data.
• Compliance Gaps: Regulatory requirements often extend to third and fourth parties, leaving you liable for violations.
• Operational Risks: Downtime or disruptions at the fourth-party level can directly affect your services.
• Reputational Damage: Publicized failures in the extended supply chain can erode trust in your brand.

Third-Party vs. Fourth-Party Risks: What’s the Difference?

Aspect	Third-Party Risks	Fourth-Party Risks
Definition	Risks posed by vendors you directly engage with.	Risks introduced by your vendors’ vendors.
Visibility	Easier to monitor through contracts and direct oversight.	Often harder to detect due to lack of direct relationships.
Examples	Data breaches at your cloud provider.	Breaches at your cloud provider’s subcontractor.
Control	Stronger contractual and operational control.	Limited control; reliant on third parties for monitoring.

While third-party risks are typically well-managed, fourth-party risks often slip under the radar due to their indirect nature. However, adopting a 4th-party system can provide the tools and frameworks to manage these risks effectively.

Strategies for Effective Fourth-Party Risk Management

1. Enhance Visibility Across the Supply Chain

Mapping your vendor ecosystem is the first step. Platforms like Centraleyes provide visibility into the network of third and fourth parties, identifying dependencies and potential vulnerabilities.

Key actions:

• Use advanced tools to automate vendor relationship mapping.
• Request detailed third-party risk management reports from your vendors.

2. Leverage Contractual Controls

Contracts with third parties can extend your oversight to fourth parties. Include clauses requiring:

• Disclosure of critical fourth-party relationships.
• Notification of any changes in fourth-party suppliers.
• Access to audit reports and cybersecurity assessments.

3. Integrate Fourth-Party Monitoring into Your TPRM Program

Your third-party risk management (TPRM) monitoring framework should include fourth-party considerations. Best practices include:

• Reviewing vendor SOC 2 reports to assess their vendor management practices.
• Monitoring changes in your third parties’ subcontractors and their performance.

4. Prioritize Critical Fourth Parties

Not all fourth parties pose the same risk. Focus on those tied to critical business functions or high-risk activities. For instance:

• Fourth parties managing sensitive customer data.
• Subcontractors providing key IT infrastructure or services.

5. Conduct Regular Risk Assessments

Continuous assessment is vital. Tools like automated questionnaires, performance reviews, and real-time monitoring help keep tabs on your extended vendor network.

6. Collaborate with Vendors on Risk Mitigation

Fourth-party risk isn’t solely your responsibility. Work with your vendors to:

• Strengthen their TPRM programs.
• Address gaps in their vendor oversight practices.

Fourth-Party Risk Management: Practical Impacts by Sector

Financial Institutions: DORA and Beyond

The Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA) in the EU sets a gold standard for operational resilience, emphasizing not just third-party oversight but the entire supply chain of service providers. Financial institutions are tasked with ensuring their vendors have robust risk management practices, including oversight of critical subcontractors.

• Financial organizations assess their vendors’ sub-outsourcing agreements to determine if these fourth parties meet resilience standards. This involves ensuring financial data isn’t compromised during transmission, storage, or processing at multiple points in the chain.
• DORA requires contingency planning for critical ICT service failures, even if the problem arises at the fourth-party level. Banks also conduct regular stress tests of these extended vendor relationships, mimicking real-world disruptions.

Healthcare: HIPAA, GDPR, and the Critical Data Web

In healthcare, patient privacy and data security dominate regulatory concerns. Both HIPAA (in the U.S.) and GDPR (in Europe) mandate that organizations ensure the security of sensitive data, even when outsourced to vendors or their subcontractors.

• Healthcare providers often work with electronic health record (EHR) systems managed by third-party vendors. Fourth parties—such as cloud storage providers for these EHR systems—are vetted to confirm they comply with encryption, access control, and breach notification requirements.
• Breach reporting frameworks like GDPR Article 28 specifically require that data controllers (healthcare entities) ensure contracts extend data protection obligations to processors and their subcontractors.

Technology: Managing Dependencies in the Cloud

The tech industry’s reliance on open-source software and cloud-based services creates sprawling ecosystems. Frameworks like ISO/IEC 27001 and SOC 2 encourage organizations to look beyond their immediate suppliers to fourth parties like open-source library maintainers or upstream cloud service providers.

• Organizations perform dependency mapping to identify critical services that could cascade failures downstream. For example, if a cloud service vendor relies on a fourth-party DNS provider, companies assess both parties for reliability.
• Many tech companies employ software composition analysis (SCA) tools to scan for vulnerabilities in third- and fourth-party dependencies, reducing risks tied to supply chain attacks like Log4j.

Retail: Payment Systems and Logistics

Retailers depend heavily on payment processors, logistics companies, and marketing platforms. A hiccup at the fourth-party level—such as a failure at a logistics vendor’s subcontracted warehouse—can trigger supply chain bottlenecks and financial losses.

• Retailers rely increasingly on real-time monitoring tools to track delivery performance and uptime of payment system.
• Some retail frameworks, like PCI DSS, require vendors to ensure secure cardholder data environments in-house and across downstream partners.

Critical Infrastructure: National Security at Stake

In critical industries like energy, telecommunications, and water systems, fourth-party risk extends to national security. The NIS 2 Directive in Europe and similar U.S. initiatives stress oversight of extended supply chains.

• Risk management frameworks include mandating contractual flow-down clauses that enforce the same security protocols for subcontractors.
• Many entities are now required to file incident reports for disruptions caused by downstream providers, even if they aren’t directly under contract.

How Technology Simplifies Fourth-Party Risk Management

Modern risk management platforms like Centraleyes simplify the complexity of fourth-party systems. Here’s how:

• Centralized Dashboards: Gain a comprehensive view of your vendor network.
• Automated Insights: Receive alerts about potential fourth-party risks.
• Scalability: Manage risk across hundreds of third- and fourth-party relationships.

Such platforms empower businesses, especially banks, to maintain compliance while proactively addressing emerging risks in their extended supply chains.

Centraleyes provides the visibility security teams need to tackle this challenge head-on. Its platform dives into the layers of your supply chain, offering clarity on fourth-party relationships that were once obscured. This capability is particularly crucial for:

• Banking: Exposing risks in payment processing systems, cloud infrastructure, or outsourced development teams.
• Healthcare: Identifying vulnerabilities in EHR platforms, data storage services, or compliance with HIPAA requirements through your vendors’ networks.

By uncovering these hidden layers, Centraleyes helps security teams proactively address risks and reinforce resilience where it matters most. 

Why stop at third-party assessments when the next layer could pose an even greater threat? 

Centraleyes equips you with acute visibility into your vendor ecosystem.